On this page
The main differences between a usufruct and a lease
1. A usufruct is a real property right whilst a lease is a contractual right
A usufruct is a real property right that is transferable to others.
Lease agreements can only be novated to others with the agreement of all parties.
It should be possible to treat a usufruct as an asset that can be mortgaged.
A long lease cannot be used as an asset for security, as it is not a real property right.
2. A lease must be for a specified period of time, whereas a usufruct can be for a specified or indeterminate period of time
The CTL permits usufructs to be for indeterminate periods, and so may be treated as an asset for the full duration of a project, without limitation.
If a usufruct is for an indeterminate time, then it would expire on the beneficiary’s death.
3. Leases must have rental consideration, whereas usufructs do not have to have a form of consideration (although they can do)
Usufructs have typically been used in situations where the land owner has not received consideration for the granting of the usufruct, such as allocations of land to or by State-owned entities.
4. Leases must be for exclusive possession, whereas usufructs do not have to be exclusive
One of the cornerstones of a lease agreement is that the leased property is for the sole use of the lessee.
A usufruct differs, as it provides a right to benefit from the land but this does not have to be exclusive.
When would an easement be used instead of a lease or usufruct?
If the right over land is for the benefit of another person’s land
An easement is a real property right that provides a benefit to one person’s land over another person’s land.
Example: a right for a person to cross a neighbour’s land to access their own if access is otherwise impossible or very onerous. The benefit stays with the land, not the person who owns the land.
