On this page
Zamakhchary & Co. (Z&Co.) has secured a successful outcome on appeal for a Saudi industrial client before the Commercial Court in Dammam. The appeal circuit set aside a first-instance judgment that had ordered our client to pay its former IT service provider a substantial sum, and dismissed the provider’s claim in full.
Key takeaways
- Base fees for the notice period refused: the appeal circuit rejected a service provider’s claim for contractual base fees covering a 90-day termination notice period in which it performed no work.
- Notice period seen as transitional: the court treated the notice period as a mechanism to organise an orderly exit, not as a paid extension of the contract, reasoning that fees under a services (muqawala) contract are tied to services actually performed.
- Damages, not fees: the court indicated that a provider’s remedy if it considered a notice period to have been breached is compensation for proven loss under Article 107 of the Civil Transactions Law.
- A fact-specific decision: the ruling turned on the wording of the contract and the evidence, and should not be read as a general rule.
What happened?
Commercial Court in Dammam, appeal circuit
- The situation
- a two-year ERP support contract with a fixed monthly base fee and 90 days’ notice. Our client gave notice; the provider did no work and claimed the base fee for the full notice period.
- Our approach
- appealed the first-instance judgment. A notice period does not create a right to fees where no work is done, and the provider bore the burden of proving performance.
- The outcome
- judgment set aside; the claim dismissed in full.
Our client, a Saudi industrial company, had a two-year contract with a software and IT support provider to maintain its enterprise resource planning (ERP) system. The provider was entitled to a fixed monthly base fee, covering on-call availability and a set number of support hours, with hourly rates for hours above that allowance. Either party could terminate on 90 days’ notice.
Our client gave notice of termination as it had replaced the system. The provider performed no work after notice was given, and our client made no further payments. The provider then claimed, among other things, the monthly base fee for the full 90-day notice period.
The court of first instance largely upheld the claim, treating the contract as continuing through the notice period. Z&Co. appealed on our client’s behalf, arguing that a notice period does not create a right to fees where no work is done and that the provider bore the burden of proving performance. The appeal circuit accepted those arguments, set aside the first-instance judgment, decided the case itself under Article 78(3) of the Commercial Courts Law, and dismissed the claim in full.

Why did the court refuse base fees for the notice period?
The fee follows the work. The court characterised the contract as a muqawala (contracting) contract for continuing services, governed by the general rules of Islamic jurisprudence and the Civil Transactions Law. It reasoned that remuneration under such a contract is linked to the agreed service actually being performed, rather than to the contract merely remaining in existence.
The notice period was not a paid extension. In its view, the 90-day notice period was intended to regulate the termination process and give both parties a transitional period, and did not of itself create a right to fees without actual performance.
“The notice period was intended to regulate the termination process and give both parties a transitional period.”
The provider bore the burden of proof. Applying Articles 2 and 3 of the Law of Evidence, the court held that the provider had to prove it performed services after notice was given. The first-instance court had wrongly required our client to prove a negative.
How far does the decision go?
Practical points for service contracts in Saudi Arabia
Frequently asked questions
Can a service provider in Saudi Arabia claim base fees for a notice period if it does no work?
In this case, the appellate court said no. It held that the 90-day notice period served to organise termination and did not entitle the provider to base fees where no services were performed.
What can a service provider claim if a customer does not honour a notice period?
The court indicated that the appropriate claim was for compensation for actual, proven harm under Article 107 of the Civil Transactions Law, rather than the full contractual fee for the notice period.
Would the result be the same if the contract expressly required payment during the notice period?
Not necessarily. The court was interpreting a notice clause that did not expressly provide for fees during notice. A clearly drafted minimum-commitment, take-or-pay or standby-fee clause could lead to a different result.
Reviewing your service contracts? Speak to our Litigation & Contentious (Disputes) team.
Get in touchHow Z&Co. can help
This result reflects Z&Co.’s experience in commercial litigation before the Saudi Commercial Courts, including on appeal. We represent clients in commercial disputes and arbitration, and advise on drafting service, IT and government contracts.
